Article Archive

Takeover Accomplished Through Deception
By Tim Palmer, ABP

COLUMBIA, Mo. (ABP) - In his strongest remarks on record to date, a longtime missions leader claimed conservatives gained control of the Southern Baptist Convention through deception.

"This whole takeover was based on deceit, on lying, on cheating," said Keith Parks, former president of the SBC agency now known as the International Mission Board. Parks took early retirement from the Richmond, Va., agency, then called the Foreign Mission Board, in 1992 because of philosophical differences with an increasingly conservative board of trustees. While he has previously criticized convention leaders for allowing controversy to override the denomination's main priority of cooperative missions, Parks' recent remarks are his most pointed against Southern Baptists' current leaders.

Parks, who recently retired as global-missions coordinator of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, spoke four times May 8-11 in Missouri. He was invited by Mainstream Missouri Baptists, a moderate group formed to defend the state against the so-called "conservative resurgence" that took control of the SBC during the 1980s.

Unite behind doctrine or missions?

Parks, at one time among the SBC's most respected leaders, said Southern Baptists came together in 1845 for missions, unifying a regionally and theologically diverse group of churches.

"There were a lot of differences and disagreements, but the consensus was, 'Let's unite behind the gospel and share it with the world,'" Parks said.

Parks described conversations he once had with former SBC president Adrian Rogers, who countered that doctrine - not missions - is what has held Southern Baptists together.

Evidence that Rogers' view has prevailed is seen in the fact that Independent Baptist Jerry Falwell now is in the theological center of Southern Baptist leaders, Parks said. "(Falwell) hasn't moved, but SBC leadership has moved to where he's been all along," Parks said.

Lessons learned

Parks said he learned several lessons from watching and being removed from leadership for refusing to embrace the conservative takeover of the SBC.

One, he said, is the battle was not, as conservatives claimed, over theology.

"Never one time did anyone try to accuse me of not believing the Bible," he said. "They'd say, 'If you support the conservative resurgence, you can stay.'"

Most of Parks' FMB presidency spanned the first decade of the conservative movement's rise. He recalled leaders repeatedly insisting they wanted only parity.

Once they succeeded in gaining complete control in 1990 when the SBC met in New Orleans, however, they celebrated the achievement. "They sat there and bragged about the fact that they had lied and cheated and deceived," Parks said.

Parks voiced dismay at what happened once the takeover was complete. "The people called Baptists didn't even blink," he said. "They said, 'We'll follow these guys who acted unbiblically.'"

As conservatives moved to exclude people who weren't committed to their political takeover, Parks continued, the whole nature of the SBC annual meeting changed. "Missions night," which had been the big event, became overshadowed by the election of a president.

Baptists have always disagreed, Parks said, but they formerly sought to change minds through persuasion. Now, he charged, Southern Baptist leaders resort to coercion and control, with rewards for those who do as they're told. "There are preachers who are afraid to come to this meeting tonight," he said to illustrate.

Parks said the SBC has shifted from being "confessional," where churches voluntarily unite around similar beliefs, to "creedal," where orthodoxy is a requirement for inclusion.

He described the mindset of current SBC leaders as: "This is what you must believe, and we'll decide if you do." Parks described this approach as making decisions based on legalism instead of grace.

Parks said he believes if Baptists across the land really understood what has happened, they would rise in opposition to the convention's conservative leaders.

One example of how churches suffer, Parks said, is that many congregations continue the habit of hiring ministers who are graduates of Southern Baptist seminaries, even though those seminaries no longer teach traditional Southern Baptist views.

Parks concluded by quoting a philosopher who said, "All it takes for evil to prevail is for good people to do nothing."

In an interview after his speech, Parks said he broke his public silence about SBC leaders only because he had been asked to speak on Baptist principles and on what happened in the SBC.

"Usually I'm asked to speak on missions," he explained. Parks said he doesn't enjoy criticizing the takeover. "It's an unpleasant task," he said, "because it's a tragic thing that has happened to Southern Baptists."

Open or closed meetings?

Organizers of Project 1000 - the Missouri Baptist Laymen's Association effort to consolidate conservatives' control in Missouri - also had a statewide meeting May 9 in Jefferson City.

Both sides are gearing up for the Oct. 30-Nov. 1 state convention meeting, where conservatives hope to elect their third consecutive president.

Project 1000 leader Roger Moran declined a request to admit a reporter to the May 9 meeting, which took place in Jefferson City.

"Our meetings are closed," Moran said. "That's the way we like it, and that's the way we're going to keep it." He denied the organization has anything to hide, however. "Our agenda is to tell the truth to people."

July 2000